The Ministry of Finance Budgets Division opposes the invoice on exemption from army service for haredim, arguing that “this association won’t result in a rise within the variety of these conscripted from among the many male haredi inhabitants, and won’t make potential a discount within the variety of reserve responsibility days affecting the financial system and a decreasing of the burden on those that serve within the IDF.” In a letter to the authorized counsel of the Knesset Overseas Affairs and Protection Committee, the Budgets Division states that the invoice will result in the lack of tens of billions of shekels to the financial system yearly and to a heavier burden on reserve troopers.
Final Thursday, Boaz Bismuth, the chairperson of the Knesset Overseas Affairs and Protection Committee, offered a draft of the invoice on exemption from conscription for haredim. The invoice, the purpose of which is “to regularize the standing of Yeshiva college students,” was offered after approval by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and after the Excessive Courtroom of Justice dominated that, within the absence of a regulation regularizing exemptions, inside 45 days the federal government should formulate financial and civil sanctions on those that don’t adjust to call-ups for army service.
Bismuth’s present proposal cancels the requirement within the earlier model of the invoice for a quota of fight troopers and sanctions such because the denial of a driving license and a prohibition on exiting the nation till age 26 for many who fail to be conscripted.
“The association results in the rapid restoration of many of the financial advantages presently denied to these obliged to be conscripted in a approach that can detract from the incentives to serve within the military,” The Budgets Division writes. “Furthermore, we consider that the sanctions mechanism, the aim of which is to encourage and supply incentives for younger haredi males to hitch the IDF won’t obtain its purpose, within the mild of using communal conscription targets, the sorts of sanctions within the association, the timing of the applying and expiration of the sanctions, and different lacunae.
“There exists a considerable concern that this association may seem like a mechanism that features efficient sanctions when in apply it really works in the other way, weakening the present array of incentives and damaging the flexibility to supply a solution to the IDF’s acute manpower wants. Equally, included within the association are mechanisms that can hurt significantly the combination of the haredi male inhabitants in financial exercise and within the labor market. Because of this, this association has important adverse financial penalties, estimated at tens of billions of shekels yearly, and, wanting forward, may have a seamless adverse impression on the Israeli financial system.”
The Budgets Division mentions that, in keeping with the IDF’s representatives, there may be an instantaneous must broaden the variety of males doing obligatory service by 12,000 further troopers. These wants are presently met by intensive drafting of reserves, and the month-to-month value to the financial system of every soldier on reserve responsibility is NIS 50,000. “The annual financial value will quantity to tens of billions of shekels. That is over and above the heavy prices which have already gathered from the scope of reserve responsibility for the reason that starting of the struggle, estimated at NIS 120 billion within the lack of financial exercise and over NIS 70 billion in direct budgetary prices of financing reserve service,” the letter states.
Revealed by Globes, Israel enterprise information – en.globes.co.il – on December 2, 2025.
© Copyright of Globes Writer Itonut (1983) Ltd., 2025.
